New Trier shortstop Kevin Donahue and Glenbrook North left-hander Tommy Gertner head up The North Shore Weekend Diamond Kings. Here’s our 2016-17 All-Area Baseball Team.
Photography by Joel Lerner, George Pfoertner and Ting Shen.
DIAMOND KINGS
Gold List
Player of the Year: Kevin Donahue (New Trier, Sr.)
![]()
Pitcher of the Year: Tommy Gertner (Glenbrook North, Sr.)
![]()
Rookie of the Year: Chris Karasinski (GBN, So.)
![]()
Newcomer of the Year: Cam Redding (NT, Jr.)
![]()
• First Team
First Baseman: Anthony Calarco (NT, Jr.)
Middle Infielder (SS): Kevin Donahue (NT, Sr.)
Middle Infielder (SS): Ryan Lin-Peistrup (Loyola Academy, Sr.)
Third Baseman: Cameron Pauly (Glenbrook South, Sr.)
Outfielder: Drew Bartholow (LA, Sr.)
Outfielder: Matt Kann (NT, Sr.)
Outfielder: Jimmy Karfis (GBN, Jr.)
Catcher: Brian Vance (LA, Sr.)
Designated Hitter: Cam Redding (NT, Jr.)
Pitcher: Tommy Gertner (GBN, Sr.)
Pitcher: Thomas Nugent (NT, Sr.)
Pitcher: Paul Turelli (LF, Sr.)
![]()
First Baseman: New Trier’s Anthony Calarco
![]()
Middle Infielder (SS): New Trier’s Kevin Donahue
![]()
Middle Infielder (SS): Loyola Academy’s Ryan Lin-Peistrup
![]()
Third Baseman: Glenbrook South’s Cam Pauly
![]()
Outfielder: Loyola Academy’s Andrew Bartholow
![]()
Oufielder: GBN’s Jimmy Karfis (bottom)
![]()
Catcher: Loyola Academy’s Brian Vance
![]()
Designated Hitter: New Trier’s Cam Redding
![]()
Pitcher: New Trier’s Thomas Nugent
![]()
Pitcher: Lake Forest High School’s Paul Turelli
• Second Team
First Baseman: Charlie Reinkemeyer (LF, Sr.)
Middle Infielder (SS): Caleb Durbin (LF, Jr.)
Middle Infielder (SS): Noah Shutan (Highland Park, Jr.)
Third Baseman: Thano Fourlas (HP, Sr.)
Outfielder: Kevin Burnside (GBN, Sr.)
Outfielder: Brad Czerniejewski (LF, Sr.)
Outfielder: Tyler Gussis (HP, Jr.)
Catcher: Dylan Horvitz (NT, Sr.)
Designated Hitter: Jake Cirame (LF Academy, Sr.)
Pitcher: Henry Haracz (LA, Jr.)
Pitcher: Jake Mandel (HP, Sr.)
Pitcher: Patrick McKermitt (LA, Jr.)
• Third Team
First Baseman: Drew Golde (LF, Jr.)
Middle Infielder (2B): Andrew Gough (LF, Jr.)
Middle Infielder (SS): Cam Judge (LFA, Sr.)
Third Baseman: David Rubin (GBN, Jr.)
Outfielder: Sean Douaire (NT, Sr.)
Outfielder: Eric Nicholas (NT, Sr.)
Outfielder: Henry Singer (HP, Sr.)
Catcher: Alex Gamache (LFA, Sr.)
Designated Hitter: Brandon Matias (GBS, So.)
Pitcher: Jack Arnstein (HP, Sr.)
Pitcher: Rich Campbell (LA, Sr.)
Pitcher: Logan Shaughnessy (LFA, Jr.)
• Fourth Team
First Baseman: Matthew Raymond (LA, Jr.)
Middle Infielder (SS): Chris Karasinski (GBN, So.)
Middle Infielder (2B): Mike Snow (GBS, Jr.)
Third Baseman: Matt Rozsypal (LFA, Jr.)
Outfielder: Jack Anderson (GBS, Jr.)
Outfielder: Trey Torain (LA, Jr.)
Outfielder: Sean Tully (LA, Sr.)
Catcher: Jack Kramer (HP, Jr.)
Designated Hitter: Andrew Athenson (LF, Sr.)
Pitcher: Evan Barnes (GBN, Jr.)
Pitcher: Peter Turelli (LF, So.)
Pitcher: Jack Zeidler (HP, Sr.)
SPECIAL AWARDS
Best Two-Way Player: Lake Forest’s Paul Turelli (Illinois State recruit hit .304 with 18 RBI as starting catcher. Despite never pitching in high school, turned into an ace, allowing 27 hits and amassing 52 strikeouts in 39.2 innings)
• Mound Aces
Best Left-hander: GBN’s Tommy Gertner (made 11 starts and went 9-1 with 1.56 ERA. Allowed 39 hits in 62.2 IP with 82 Ks and 16 walks)
Best Right-hander: NT’s Thomas Nugent (finished 12-2 with 0.92 ERA, walked 10 and allowed 48 hits in 68.2 IP)
Best out of the Bullpen: New Trier’s Sean Douaire (starred on the mound during playoffs, ended up 3-1 with a 1.88 ERA)
• Silver Bats
Best Power Swing: NT’s Kevin Donahue (a true power-hitting shortstop, smacked 15 doubles and hit .412)
Best Gap Hitter: NT’s Anthony Calarco (switch-hitter who uses all fields, finished with 13 doubles and 2 home runs)
Toughest Out: HP’s Noah Shutan (hit .386 with a state-best 48 walks. Had .618 on-base percentage)
• Gold Gloves
Best Defensive Infielder: Loyola’s Ryan Lin-Peistrup (slick-fielding shortstop with outstanding range is a University of Illinois-Chicago recruit)
Best Defensive Outfielder: Highland Park’s Henry Singer (covers a ton of ground with great instincts and speed — 23 steals)
Best Double Play Combination: Lake Forest’s Caleb Durbin (shortstop) and Andrew Gough (second baseman)
Best Behind the Plate: LA’s Brian Vance (St. Joseph University recruit excels at handling pitchers, throwing out runners and blocking pitches in the dirt)